LEADING BY EXAMPLE
Breaking the cycle of poverty
Led by dedicated staff and an involved board of directors, Shepherd Community Center applies management best practices and biblical values to all of our programs and planning.
Senior Leadership
Jay Height
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
An ordained minister with a background in journalism and philanthropy, Jay has served at Shepherd since 1995 and as Executive Director since the Fall of 1997. His longstanding connections with the community and vision for a revitalized city inspire Shepherd’s staff and neighbors as well as our civic, institutional, and corporate partners.
Andrew Green
ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Andrew began his career working with at-risk youth and children in Detroit and continued that commitment while getting his Masters of Social Work at the University of Michigan. In 2006, he joined Shepherd’s staff, and has since held several strategic and leadership positions. In addition to his work at Shepherd, Andrew serves on his church board and is active in the community.
Dr. Timothy Streett
CHIEF LEARNING OFFICER
A scholar with a passion for poverty alleviation, Tim helped to build Shepherd’s unique 10 Assets format for breaking the cycle of poverty. He provides valuable philosophical and strategic direction for Shepherd’s programs. Tim and his family have lived and worked among the poor for 38 years, most of that time in the Martindale-Brightwood neighborhood of Indianapolis. He has a significant teaching ministry and leads Shepherd’s educational outreach to partners and stakeholders, which includes developing and teaching Poverty 101. Timothy has a BA from Purdue University, an MDiv from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, and a PhD from Bellarmine University. He is married to Stacy, a School Media Specialist, who has been a partner in ministry for 30 years. They have two adult children.
Kolton Williford
CHIEF DEVELOPMENT OFFICER
Kolton has served at Shepherd since 2015. He desires authentic relationships and helps our donors, partners, and volunteers use their passions and skills to further Shepherd’s mission. While at Shepherd, Kolton has served as a Major Gift and Corporate Relations Officer as well as Director of Development before stepping into his current position in 2024. As the Chief Development Officer, Kolton oversees marketing, communications, development, and donor events. Kolton leads with compassion and humility, always willing to lend a helping hand no matter the job. Kolton has a Bachelor’s in Intercultural Studies from Olivet Nazarene University. He and his wife, Sarah Ann, have two beautiful daughters.
Phil Edwards
Chief Engagement Officer
With more than 30 years of experience in community development, Phil has a passion for cultivating authentic relationships among people from different ethnic and socio-economic groups. His vision for Shepherd volunteers is mutual transformation—that each person who serves will develop skills and build lasting relationships with our neighbors.
Jason Courtney
CHIEF OF STAFF
Jason’s connection with Shepherd Community began in his teens, volunteering with his youth group. After serving on the mission field, he returned to Shepherd as a place to invest his gifts and calling. In his current role, he helps lead organizational strategy and operations at Shepherd. With a background in business and international missions, Jason brings both strategic insight and a heart for relationships. He is passionate about building systems that make ministry more effective and sustainable, aligning Shepherd’s day-to-day operations with its vision to break the cycle of poverty through Christ-centered, holistic engagement.
Bekah Kidd
Chief Program Officer
Starting in the Shepherd Fellowship Program in 2012, Bekah now serves as Chief Program Officer. With a Bachelor’s in Christian Education (2011) and MBA (2020) from Olivet Nazarene University, Bekah oversees our Elementary-High school Before-School, After-School, and Summer programs, Shepherd’s College and Career Program, Alumni program, Library and STEM programs, Health, Nutrition, and Counseling programs, and Family Engagement programs, including employment coaching, financial coaching, and case management programs for adult neighbors. Ensuring these teams have what they need to be effective and focused on the mission of Shepherd without hindrances or distractions. Bekah’s vision for Shepherd programs is to be a cohesive and supportive team that works to ensure the whole family is moving towards reduced dependency by continuously reinventing programs to better fit and support families’ needs. “Our programming revolves around relationships with each other and our neighbors. This means all our programs should deepen relationships with neighbors, and these relationships should also play a part in how our programs operate.”
Dr. Bethany Morford
CHIEF EDUCATION OFFICER
Bethany Morford has served at Shepherd Community since 2022 and brings more than 20 years of experience teaching children and leading teams in education, financial services, and ministry. She holds a degree in Early Childhood Education from Penn View Bible Institute, a Master’s in Educational Administration, and a Ph.D. in Educational Leadership from Columbia International University. Her cross-cultural work in Ukraine, decades of teaching children in ministries and schools, and service as a foster parent to 42 children reflect her lifelong commitment to helping children thrive and become lifelong learners.
Wes Terry
CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER
Wes provides financial support and leadership for all areas of Shepherd Community Center. He is a CPA and has both a BS and an MBA in Accounting from Indiana University. With over 10 years of accounting and finance experience, Wes has held various roles, from auditor to CFO to instructor. He has a heart for supporting nonprofits in their mission to serve others and has dedicated his career to this unique sector. Outside of work, he enjoys spending time with his wife and three young boys, being outdoors, traveling, and volunteering in his community.
Allen Southerland
CHIEF RECRUITMENT OFFICER
Drawing on more than 30 years in ministry, including denominational leadership and nearly a decade on Shepherd’s Board of Directors, Allen came on staff to more fully develop the Leadership Pipeline. In that role, he oversees fellowship participants and interns as well as some internal staff, and develops partnerships with colleges to give students experiential learning through service at Shepherd.
Donna Alexander
DIRECTOR OF VOLUNTEER ENGAGEMENT
With a vast experience as a missionary (10 years in Zambia, Africa, and six years in Ukraine) and a teacher in both the American Embassy School and Islamic Academy in Africa, Donna brings a diverse set of skills to Shepherd, including leadership training, literacy development, and managing a variety of volunteer opportunities and teams from around the world. In her role as Director of Volunteers, Donna helps recruit and equip individuals and groups to volunteer at Shepherd to significantly impact our community. “My vision for volunteers is to help them learn, build relationships, and bridge the gap of cultural barriers to help further the mission of Shepherd to break the cycle of poverty.”
Edson Solares
Director of HR/I.T.
Edson has served the Shepherd team since 2013 in various roles, but with his Bachelor’s in Computer Science (2013) and MBA (2015), Edson brings a unique and robust skill set to his current role as Director of HR & IT. Edson empowers the staff both emotionally and technologically. Edson sees his role as “taking care of the less fun stuff so current and future staff can concentrate on what they do best!”
Curtis Adkins
DIRECTOR EASTSIDE YOUTH COLLABORATIVE
Curtis rejoined the Shepherd Community Center staff in April 2024 as the Director of the Eastside Youth Collaborative. Prior to this role, he served for three years as the Director of City Life Wheels for Central Indiana Youth for Christ. Curtis earned his bachelor’s degree in 2004 from Ohio Valley University in Parkersburg, West Virginia. After graduating, he returned to his hometown of Indianapolis to serve the community that shaped him—specifically through Shepherd Community Center, which had played a pivotal role in his own life. Over the course of 16 years at Shepherd, Curtis served in a variety of roles, ranging from direct community services to leading and facilitating programs. He also held the position of Chief Operating Officer for several years. In addition to his work at Shepherd, Curtis serves on the board of River Valley Resources. He lives in Indianapolis with his wife, Michelle, and their three children: Malachi, Mikaiah, and Micah.
Board of Directors
Ben Lotter
Board Chairman, Executive, Facilities, & Finance Committee Chairs / Project Executive, Messer Construction
Robby Phillips
Board Vice Chairman, Executive Committee / Owner, One Stop Marketing
Richard Cherry
Board Treasurer, Finance Committee / Chief Information Officer, SAFEbuilt
Mike Smith
Board Member, Program Committee / Retired EVP & CFO, Anthem, Inc
Steven Emch
Board Member / President, Orr Fellowship
Tim George
Board Member / CEO, Pathemy Strategies
Jose Juarez
Board Member / Family and Community Engagement Director, Indianapolis Public Schools
John Kuykendall
Board Member / Dean, School of Education, University of Indianapolis
Ashley Overley
Board Member / VP for Mental Health Operations, Eskenazi Health
